When brands collide: how to avoid an identity crisis when your company consolidates
I don’t know about you, but I’ve noticed a lot of stories in the local business news of trust companies consolidating with larger partners. Think Opera’s buyout of Accuro, Summit Group’s acquisition of R&H Jersey, and Cavendish Fiduciary’s acquisition of GlenQ Private Wealth. It got me thinking… How does the surviving brand continue to thrive when you merge two separate, distinct groups of people and cultures?
A brand merger might sound thrilling on the outside, offering more resources, a broader reach, and the excitement of “bigger is better.” However, with trust companies consolidating at an unprecedented pace in Jersey, a familiar challenge bubbles up beneath the glossy headlines of 'we’re growing', to how do you protect your brand’s heart when you suddenly have a whole new group of people joining?
Let’s imagine you’ve built a robust, reputable brand over the years. Your values are clear. Your tone, your client touchpoints, and your social footprint all align. However, now that you’re merging with another business, their team has spent the last decade with a different set of values. Their culture? Their ways of working? Likely to be very different to yours. Bringing it all together is not just an operational headache; it could be an identity crisis in the making.
When trust companies consolidate, it’s easy to initially focus on the incumbent and surviving websites, logos, or letterheads. However, anyone who has weathered a merger knows that the real work happens deep inside the coop. Your focus must be on the culture, the people, and their sense of belonging (mergers can be scary and unnerving for some). A business’s culture underpins everything about a brand; it’s far more important than the logo or a fancy website. And nothing chips away at a strong brand identity faster than clashing values, or silent “us versus them” divides.
You might have a playbook for these kinds of moves, but people rarely fit into neat little boxes. One team prizes formality and process; the other is known for informality and speed. One group swears by their Friday breakfast rituals of crispy bacon rolls from The Taste, while the other by their after-hours pub sessions. Or, separate from the fun stuff, by how decisions are made, or how clients get treated. It’s subtle, but essential to consider.
When companies with distinct brands merge, the danger isn’t just confusion for clients. There’s a real risk the loudest voice wins, or worse, nobody feels heard at all. A once-proud brand can become bland, generic, or inconsistent. It may lose its edge in the change. And, most damaging of all, team morale can dive, fueling turnover and sapping the momentum your Board had planned and aimed to achieve.
So, what can you do to protect the consolidated brand? Here are six key considerations to keep in mind when consolidating with another company.
1. Acknowledge the elephant in the room
Don’t pretend there aren’t differences or that “we’re all the same.” Have open conversations about what makes each brand tick: what’s cherished, what people are nervous about losing, and what’s worth keeping or letting go. This isn’t about running a tick-box consultation; it’s about active listening, a genuine exchange of ideas, and carefully considering feedback. When your team feels heard, they feel valued and are more likely to stay.
2. Find out where you meet in the middle
Map out where the brands (and their cultures) connect. What values do both organisations share? What’s non-negotiable for your surviving brand, and what unique traditions or quirks could the new team bring to strengthen you? Sometimes the most vibrant new cultures are forged by blending the best of both, not diluting one for the other.
3. Re-position your north star
At the Board level, revisit your core purpose and values, ensuring you seek input from both sides. Rearticulate what you stand for, and ensure it’s visible and actionable for everyone going forward. This is your compass when decisions get tough or old habits start creeping in.
4. Keep your people at the centre of your future
Remember, for a brand to successfully survive a merger, it’s the people that matter the most, not the processes. It is they who build trust and brand reputation. Give teams opportunities to bond, work together, and even co-create aspects of the new culture. Cross-team projects, or social initiatives, can break down barriers and build new loyalties.
5. Communication, communication, communication, did I say that loud enough?
Share updates, wins, and even setbacks as you go. Ensure you lead with transparency. Talk openly about what’s changing, why decisions are made, and where everyone fits with the changes. People need to know what’s in it for them and how these changes will affect them. If you don’t do that, speculation will become rife in the office. Hushed whispers by the water cooler can cause more damage than any carefully laid-out plans. Also, make space for staff feedback and demonstrate how it’s actually shaping your brand journey.
6. Find your brand champions
When a significant change occurs, such as a merger or acquisition, some will embrace it, while others will fear it and appear resistant. It’s essential in the early stages to identify your “brand ambassadors” from both legacy teams. They are the people who genuinely believe in what you’re building and can model new ways of working. They’re crucial for keeping culture on track and helping new joiners buy into your story.
Ultimately, mergers are as much about people as they are about the process. A spreadsheet can show a perfect fit on paper, but culture and brand loyalty are built in the day-to-day, in the details, in the stories people tell after work to their friends while they’re enjoying their favourite tipple in the pub. If you nurture your combined team with clarity, humility, and purpose, we’re not just talking buzz words like rebrands and transformational workshops; you’ll protect and even deepen what makes your brand special. Because at the end of the day, your people are your most faithful brand ambassadors
Like what you’ve read?
Jo Buchanan, the author of this blog, is the Founder and Director of TwitTwooYou Limited, a business growth strategic consultancy centred on getting brands noticed. TwitTwooYou offers smart services to help businesses grow and achieve their aspirations and goals. Want to get your brand noticed? Get in touch for a free, no-obligation chat.
